Journal of Transportation Research

Journal of Transportation Research

Comparative Technical and Economic Analysis of Ramp and Mechanized Parking Systems in Urban Mixed-Use Projects in Tehran

Document Type : Review Article

Authors
Morteza Tahamipour Zarandi 1
Farhad Saeedi 2
Mohammad parsa khoshdooz 2
1 Assistant Professor, Faculty of Economics and Political Science, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran.
2 Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, Ibn Sina Faculty, Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch, Tehran, Iran.
10.22034/tri.2025.538576.3379
Abstract
The rapid growth of multi-use urban development projects in densely populated cities such as Tehran has increased the demand for efficient parking solutions that address both spatial limitations and economic constraints. This study provides a comparative techno-economic analysis of two commonly used urban parking systems: ramp-based and automated (mechanized) parking. Utilizing a systematic literature review of over 25 credible academic sources, six key performance indicators were assessed: construction cost, implementation time, parking capacity, service speed, structural lifespan, and decommissioning considerations. Automated parking systems employ advanced mechanical and control technologies to maximize land use, minimize parking structure footprint, and improve vehicle retrieval speed and accuracy. They are especially suitable for high-density areas where vertical construction is feasible. Although automated systems involve higher initial capital and maintenance costs, they offer superior spatial efficiency, reduced operational labor, and potential for higher long-term returns.
Conversely, ramp-based parking systems are simpler in design and operation. They provide easy access and reliability with minimal mechanical dependency. Economically, ramp systems demand lower initial investments, enjoy longer structural lifespans due to fewer mechanical components, and incur lower maintenance costs. However, their reliance on horizontal space makes them less appropriate for land-limited sites. The findings indicate that neither system is universally optimal; rather, the choice depends on project-specific factors including land availability, budget, zoning laws, and intended usage. Projects facing high land costs and limited space benefit from automated solutions, whereas ramp systems suit projects with more available land and tighter budget constraints.In conclusion, the study emphasizes adopting multi-criteria decision-making frameworks early in the planning process to facilitate informed, context-sensitive parking system selection in urban development.
Keywords
Ramp Parking
Mechanized Parking
Technical and Economic Analysis
Urban Mixed-Use Projects
Structural Comparison
Subjects
-Allik, P. (2018). Analysis of the construction of an open multi-storey parking and evaluation of its profitability Bachelor’s thesis, Saimaa University of Applied Sciences.
-Arhab, N., Oussalah, M., Kokkonen, H., & Ollakka, A. (2022). Analysis of car parking industry from social community perspective. Social Network Analysis and Mining, 12(162). doi.org/10.1007/s13278-022-00981-x
-Beebe, R. S. (2001, June 25). Automated parking: Status in the United States, advantages and criteria. Presented at the World Parking Symposium III, St. Andrews, Scotland.
 -Bhowmik, J., Monir, M. F., Al Naiyem, S. A., Rahman, M. A., Bhowmik, B., & Ahmed, T. (2023). Design and development of a low-cost automated parking system for developing countries. Proceedings of the 2023 IEEE EUROCON - 20th International Conference on Smart Technologies, 30–35. doi.org/10.1109/EUROCON56442.2023.10198976
-Biyik, C., Allam, Z., Pieri, G., Moroni, D., O’Fraifer, M., O’Connell, E., Olariu, S., & Khalid, M. (2021). Smart parking systems: Reviewing the literature, architecture and ways forward. Smart Cities, 4(2), 623–642. doi.org/10.3390/smartcities4020032
 -Chen, J., Chen, H., Gao, J., Dave, K., & Quaranta, R. (2021). Business models and cost analysis of automated valet parking and shared autonomous vehicles assisted by Internet of Things. Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part D: Journal of Automobile Engineering, 235(14), 1–14.
doi.org/10.1177/0954407021994445
 -Darvazeh, S. S., Ghasemi, A., Tilenoei, N. R., & Shoul, A. (2018). Locating mechanized parking in Qom with sustainable development approach (A study on the city of Qom). Journal of Urban Economics and Management, 6(21),115-130. doi.org/10.29252/iueam.6.21.111
 -Davis, A. Y., Pijanowski, B. C., Robinson, K., & Engel, B. (2010). The environmental and economic costs of sprawling parking lots in the United States. Land Use Policy, 27(2), 255–261.doi.org/10.1016/j.landusepol.2009.03.002
 -Eliasson, J., & Börjesson, M. (2022). Costs and benefits of parking charges in residential areas. Transportation Research Part B: Methodological, 166, 95–109. doi.org/10.1016/j.trb.2022.10.012
 -Ellk, D. S., Mohsin, A. H., & Hasan, S. A. (2020). Feasibility study for the establishment of a multi-story car park: A case study. The Open Civil Engineering Journal, 14(1), 179–187. doi.org/10.2174/1874149502014010179
 -Fadeyev, D. (2017). Method for evaluating economic efficiency of parking management tools. Transportation Research Procedia, 20, 193–199. doi.org/10.1016/j.trpro.2017.01.050
 -Inci, E. (2014). A review of the economics of parking. Economics of Transportation, 4(3), 50–63.
doi.org/10.1016/j.ecotra.2014.11.001
-Jog, Y., Sajeev, A., Vidwans, S., & Mallick, C. (2015). Understanding smart and automated parking technology. International Journal of u- and e- Service, Science and Technology, 8(2), 251–262. doi.org/10.14257/ijunesst.2015.8.2.25
 -Kalašová, A., Čulík, K., Poliak, M., & Otahálová, Z. (2021). Smart parking applications and its efficiency. Sustainability, 13(11), 6031. doi.org/10.3390/su13116031
 -Kalašová, A., Čulík, K., Poliak, M., & Otahálová, Z. (2021). Smart parking applications and its efficiency. Sustainability, 13(11), 6031. doi.org/10.3390/su13116031
 -Letzeiser, R. (2012). Value add and sustainable parking strategies: A financial evaluation and real estate developer perspective. Master’s Thesis, Clemson University.
 -Mikšíková, S., Ulčák, D., & Kutá, D. (2023). Assessment of automated parking garage services as a means to sustainable traffic development in a mid-sized city. Sustainability, 15(3), 2205.doi.org/10.3390/su15032205
 -Mullapudi, R. (2022). Typical parking structure problems, repairs, and cost assessment. Forensic Engineering 2022, 960–968.
 -Plihal, J., Nedoma, P., Sestak, V., Herda, Z., & Aksjonov, A. (2022). Transport automation in urban mobility: A case study of an autonomous parking system. Vehicles, 4(2), 326–343.doi.org/10.3390/vehicles4020020
 -Pramesti, S. G. G. (2020). Economic analysis on the implementation of digital parking system (Study case: Sidoarjo Regency) [Undergraduate thesis, Institut Teknologi Sepuluh Nopember].
-Prasad, K. D., Krishna, Y. V., & Manikanta, C. M. S. (2021). Advanced mechanised car parking system. International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology (IJERT), 10(06), 681–686.
 -Serpen, G., & Debnath, J. (2019). Design and performance evaluation of a parking management system for automated, multi-story and robotic parking structure. International Journal of Intelligent Computing and Cybernetics, 12(4),444–465. doi.org/10.1108/IJICC-02-2019-0017
 -Serpen, G., & Debnath, J. (2019). Design and performance evaluation of a parking management system for automated,
multi-story and robotic parking structure. International Journal of Intelligent Computing and Cybernetics, 12(4),
444–465. doi.org/10.1108/IJICC-02-2019-0017
 -Serrano, D., Torres Suárez, G., Molina Bas, O. I., & Cruzado, I. (2016). Feasibility study for the construction of multi-story parking through a public-private partnership at the University of Puerto Rico at Mayagüez. Construction Research Congress 2016, 341–350.
doi.org/10.1061/9780784479827.035
 -Švajda, M., Šoštarić, M., Ševrović, M., & Jakovljević, M. (2022, May 11-13). Comparative cost and benefit analysis of parking systems regarding the type of parking offer. 7th International Conference on Road and Rail Infrastructure (CETRA 2022), Pula, Croatia.
doi.org/10.5592/CO/CETRA.2022.1397
 -Wu, G., Xu, X., Gong, Y., De Koster, R., & Zou, B. (2018). Optimal design and planning for compact automated parking systems. European Journal of Operational Research, 15357, 1–25.
doi.org/10.1016/j.ejor.2018.09.014